• Login
  • Join PAR or Rejoin PAR
  • Current PAR Member Forms
  • Directory
  • Member Handbook
  • PAR Newsletters
  • Pay Dues
  • Advertise with PAR

Phone : 602.246.1012
facebook
twitter

  • Education
    • Education Overview
    • Education Calendar
    • Arizona CE Requirements
    • Code of Ethics Training
    • Online Courses
    • Designations & Certifications
    • Broker Education
  • Events
    • Calendar of Events
    • Valleywide Real Estate Marketing Meetings
    • 3rd Thursdays Lunch Break
  • Benefits
    • Benefits Overview
    • Arizona Regional MLS
    • Benefits from the Arizona Association
    • Benefits from the National Association
    • Facility Rental
    • PAR Store
  • Resources
    • Resources Overview
    • Arizona Department of Real Estate
    • Market Statistics
    • New REALTORS®
    • Technology
    • Housing Information
    • Resources for Home Buyers
    • Business and Information Tools
    • DR Dues Formula Explanation
  • News
    • PAR News
    • Industry News
  • Law and Ethics
    • Law and Ethics Overview
    • Legal Opinions
    • Code of Ethics
    • State & National Legal Resources
  • Political Advocacy
    • Political Advocacy Overview
    • Local Issues & Activities
    • State Issues & Activities
    • National Issues & Activities
    • RAPAC
  • About Us
    • About Us Overview
    • History
    • Photo Gallery
    • Awards
    • Board of Directors
    • Staff
    • PAR Bylaws
    • Office Hours and Location
    • Contact Us



Homeowner appeals ruling to rebuild historic property he razed

January 16, 2019
Appeals, historic, Homeowner, Property, razed, rebuild, Ruling

A real estate developer ordered to rebuild a replica of an historic home he had torn down is fighting the decision in appeals court.

Last month, the San Francisco Planning Commission ordered San Francisco homeowner Ross Johnston to build an exact replica of his 900-square-foot historic home after Johnson, a real estate developer, tore it down as part of a plan to build a new residence on the same plot of land.

“The Planning Commission decision is invalid, bizarre, and illegal,” said Andrew Zacks, the land use attorney representing Johnston, in a statement. The team of attorneys argues that the building “bore no resemblance” to the original 1930s home because it had been renovated by the city prior to Johnston’s purchase.

The home, known locally as Largent House, was designed by prominent modernist architect Richard Neutra in 1936. Johnston purchased the 49 Hopkins Avenue property in 2017 for $ 1.7 million with the intent of building a larger home for his family on the land. Even though his permit only allowed him to remodel the first floor of the house, Johnston took a backhoe and demolished the entire structure.

The move caused the ire of neighbors and preservationists worried about developers destroying San Francisco’s history in an effort to maximize profits from the land. As a result, the Planning Commission ordered Johnston to rebuild the house to exactly what it looked like in 1936 at his own expense.

But, the attorneys argue, the property Johnston purchased had already looked nothing like the original design — in 2014, a historian deemed that its original integrity had been lost due to numerous city-authorized renovations and a 1969 fire. Zacks also argues that the ruling has been “manufactured […] for political purposes with no regard to the facts or previously approved permits.”

In the coming months, an appeals court will determine whether to uphold the original land use decision.

Email Veronika Bondarenko

Inman

Social Share

Industry Archives

Recent Posts

  • 3 tips for using rapport to turn prospects into clients
  • New FAA law will require drones to display registration
  • How to launch your career in high-end real estate
  • Be your community’s #1 fan
  • 3 steps to a more productive 2019

Support our Advertisers


Consumers:

Find a Home
Find a REALTOR®
What is a REALTOR®
Why Use a REALTOR®
Home Ownership News

Learn More

Resources:

Industry News
New REALTORS®
Arizona Dept of Real Estate
Political Advocacy
Law and Ethics
Accessibility

Learn More

REALTORS®:

PAR Store
PAR Member Benefits
PAR Events
Facility Rental
Continuing Education
PAR Forms
Join PAR
Pay Dues

Contact Us:

5033 N. 19th Ave., Ste 119
Phoenix, AZ 85015
Phone: (602) 246-1012
Fax: (602) 246-1512
Office Hours and Location

Contact Us


REALTOR LogoREALTOR Logo | Advertise with PAR
© 2015 Phoenix Association of REALTORS®.  All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use